In a recent revelation, Selena Gomez addressed the reasons behind her decision to decline Justin Bieber’s proposal, a confession that’s reignited interest and debate among fans regarding the notorious Justin-Selena-Hailey love triangle. This unexpected insight has not only shifted public opinion but also stirred up past rumors surrounding Justin’s motives for marriage.
The Rumored Proposal and Speculation of Justin’s Motives
For years, fans have speculated that Justin’s decision to get married was influenced by his desire for U.S. citizenship. Rumors allege that he first proposed to Selena, but when she turned him down, he quickly pivoted to Hailey Baldwin (now Hailey Bieber). While these speculations have remained unconfirmed, they’ve only added fuel to the ever-growing fire around Justin’s relationship decisions. This raises a question that’s lingered in fans’ minds: If Justin did propose to Selena, why did she decline?
Justin’s Troubled Years and the Effect on His Relationship with Selena
Selena and Justin’s on-and-off relationship spanned nearly a decade, marked by Justin’s turbulent “Wild Child” era. Beginning in 2013, Justin’s once squeaky-clean image started to falter. A series of scandals—from illegally acquiring a pet monkey and abandoning it in Germany to controversial comments and public outbursts—painted a picture of a young star spiraling out of control. Adding to the chaos, Justin faced legal troubles, including a DUI arrest in Miami that led to a public petition demanding his deportation. The repeated headlines suggested a pattern, and for years, tabloids blamed Selena for Justin’s erratic behavior, alleging that his actions stemmed from heartbreak.
Selena’s Side of the Story
In a 2020 interview with NPR, Selena opened up about the emotional abuse she endured during her relationship with Justin, revealing that it took her time to come to terms with the effects of their time together. According to Selena, while tabloids portrayed her as a trigger for Justin’s behavior, she felt like the victim. This perspective has changed the way fans view their past relationship, with many rallying behind Selena for the courage it took to share her experience.
The Final Breakup and Justin’s Alleged Strategy for Citizenship
After a brief reconciliation in 2017, Selena and Justin split for the last time in early 2018. Rumors emerged that Justin might have been aiming to marry a U.S. citizen to secure his residency due to his past legal troubles. Celebrity gossip suggested that Justin, in his final attempt to win Selena back, had reportedly contacted her multiple times, expressing his desire to reconcile.
As the rumors suggest, Justin may have been desperate to remain in the U.S. by any means necessary. When Selena turned down his proposal, fans speculated he shifted his focus to Hailey. Only a few months after his split with Selena, he proposed to Hailey in a quick turnaround that many viewed as questionable, leading some fans to believe that Justin married Hailey for reasons beyond love.
Justin’s Admission and the Public’s Sympathy for Hailey
In recent years, Justin has admitted to struggling with an emotional breakdown after getting married, realizing that marriage wouldn’t instantly solve his problems. This candid confession led some to wonder if his marriage to Hailey was a quick fix in response to his situation at the time. Fans have noted that Justin appears somber or detached in various public appearances with Hailey, suggesting possible underlying issues.
In a telling moment in a music video for DJ Khaled’s “Popstar,” where Justin lip-syncs the lyrics, “Ariana, Selena, my visa,” fans couldn’t help but draw connections to his supposed motives for citizenship. Meanwhile, fans sympathize with Hailey, believing she may have been drawn into a situation that wasn’t entirely transparent.
Selena’s Decision and Fans’ Reactions
When asked why she turned down Justin’s rumored proposal, sources close to Selena say she chose to prioritize her happiness. She reportedly came to terms with her situation in May 2018, while still dating Justin, only to discover that he may have remained in contact with Hailey. Friends and family noted that she began to reconsider what truly mattered in her life, ultimately ending the relationship and choosing her happiness over reconciliation.
Fans have widely supported Selena’s decision, with many expressing relief that she chose her own path. One fan summarized the sentiment, saying, “So glad Selena Gomez didn’t end up marrying Justin Bieber. She deserves better.” Others speculated that Justin could be using his marriage to Hailey as a means to secure citizenship, believing he may consider a different path once the requirements are met.
The Question Remains
So, did Justin marry Hailey solely to gain U.S. citizenship? The narrative is complicated, and while there is no direct answer, the evidence has fueled endless speculation. For fans, it’s a story that brings sympathy for Hailey and relief for Selena, whose self-prioritization has been celebrated.
Do you believe Justin’s motivations for marriage were tied to citizenship? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.
