In the exhilarating world of college football, moments of surprise and bewilderment often leave fans and analysts alike asking, “What are you doing?” One such instance occurred during the 2019 College Football Playoff National Championship, where an unthinkable decision by the Georgia Bulldogs’ coaching staff had fans and commentators scratching their heads.

In a crucial game against the Alabama Crimson Tide, with the score tied and the clock winding down, Georgia faced a pivotal fourth-and-11 situation deep in Alabama territory. Instead of attempting a long field goal or going for a risky fourth-down conversion, Bulldogs’ coach Kirby Smart opted to punt the ball away. The decision was met with immediate shock from both fans and analysts, who felt that the chance to take a lead in such a critical moment was being squandered.

As it turned out, the Crimson Tide took advantage of the opportunity and scored a game-winning touchdown, leaving many to wonder if a more aggressive approach might have changed the outcome of the game.

Another perplexing moment in college football came during the 2021 Michigan vs. Michigan State game. In the closing minutes, with Michigan leading by a slim margin, the Wolverines’ defensive coordinator, Mike Macdonald, made a puzzling call to drop back into a prevent defense instead of focusing on stopping Michigan State’s ground game.

The decision allowed Michigan State’s running back, Kenneth Gainwell, to break through for a dramatic game-winning touchdown. The choice to switch defensive strategies in such a critical moment was widely criticized, with many questioning the rationale behind abandoning a more aggressive defensive stance.

These moments exemplify how college football, while filled with thrilling plays and memorable performances, also presents scenarios that leave fans exasperated and asking, “What are you doing?” They highlight the unpredictable nature of the sport and the immense pressure on coaches to make decisions that can have far-reaching consequences. Such instances remind us that college football is not just a game of athletic prowess, but also a high-stakes chess match where strategic choices are constantly under scrutiny.